Multistable perception refers to the phenomenon in which an ambiguous stimulus can be perceived in multiple, equally valid ways, and one’s perception of the stimulus can switch spontaneously or be influenced by various factors. This is also known as perceptual rivalry, as the brain seems to alternate between different possible interpretations of the stimulus.
One classic example of multistable perception is the Necker Cube, which is a wireframe cube that can be perceived as facing in one of two possible orientations, even though the physical stimulus remains the same. Another example is the Rubin vase, which can be perceived as either a vase or as two faces in profile, depending on which part of the image is given more weight by the brain.
Multistable perception is often studied in the field of psychology and neuroscience, as it can provide insights into the workings of the brain’s visual processing systems and the mechanisms of attention and perception.
Table of Contents
- How does Multistable Perception work?
- Versions of the Multistable Perception
- Illusions like Multistable Perception
- Discovery of Multistable Perception
- References and Resources
- Sign up for emails from Mental Bomb
How does the Multistable Perception work?
Multistable perception occurs when the brain is presented with an ambiguous or conflicting stimulus that can be interpreted in different ways. The brain’s visual processing systems are constantly trying to make sense of the incoming sensory information and generate a coherent perception of the world, but when there are multiple possible interpretations of the stimulus, the brain can become stuck in a state of ambiguity.
This ambiguity is thought to arise from competition between different neural populations that represent the possible interpretations of the stimulus. Each interpretation may be represented by a network of neurons that are mutually inhibitory, meaning that the activity of one population suppresses the activity of the others. When the stimulus is ambiguous, the activity of these populations can fluctuate, leading to spontaneous switches between the different interpretations of the stimulus.
In addition to these spontaneous fluctuations, multistable perception can also be influenced by various factors such as attention, context, and expectation. For example, if someone is asked to focus their attention on one particular aspect of the stimulus, this may bias their perception towards one interpretation over another.
Overall, multistable perception is a complex phenomenon that involves competition between different neural populations and can be influenced by various top-down and bottom-up factors. Its study can provide valuable insights into the workings of the brain’s visual processing systems and the mechanisms of attention and perception.
Versions of the Multistable Perception
The following are some alternate versions of Multistable Perception:
Illusions like Multistable Perception
There are many examples of multistable perception, some of which include:
- Necker Cube: A wireframe cube that can be perceived as facing in one of two possible orientations, even though the physical stimulus remains the same.
- Rubin’s vase: An image that can be perceived as either a vase or as two faces in profile, depending on which part of the image is given more weight by the brain.
- Bistable motion: A moving stimulus that can be perceived as either moving back and forth or rotating clockwise and counterclockwise.
- The spinning dancer: An image of a spinning dancer that can be perceived as spinning in either a clockwise or counterclockwise direction.
- Reversible figures: Figures that can be perceived in two different orientations, such as the duck-rabbit or the old-young woman.
- The hollow mask illusion: A mask that appears to be concave even though it is physically convex, due to the brain’s interpretation of shading and depth cues.
These examples demonstrate how the brain can generate multiple, equally valid interpretations of an ambiguous stimulus, and how these interpretations can switch spontaneously or be influenced by various factors.
Some related illusions include the following:
Penrose figures are impossible objects that were first described by the mathematician and philosopher Roger Penrose in the 1950s.
They are optical illusions that depict objects that appear to violate the laws of three-dimensional geometry. Penrose figures are typically drawn or represented as two-dimensional images, but they create the illusion of a three-dimensional object that cannot actually exist in the real world.
Some common examples of Penrose figures include the Penrose triangle, which appears to have vertices that join in impossible ways, and the Penrose stair, which appears to be a staircase that goes on forever, with the steps constantly descending and yet never reaching the bottom.
These figures challenge our perception of the world and have been used in art, architecture, and psychology to study the workings of the human mind and the limits of human perception.
The Penrose stairs, also known as the impossible staircase or the Penrose steps, is a visual illusion in the form of an impossible object created by the mathematician and physicist Roger Penrose.
The illusion is a two-dimensional representation of a staircase that appears to ascend or descend indefinitely, yet is physically impossible to climb or descend because the steps are not connected in a logical manner.
It is often used as an example of the type of optical illusion that can occur in the human brain and is used in cognitive psychology to study perception and attention.
The Penrose triangle, also known as the Penrose tribar, is an optical illusion that depicts a three-dimensional object that is physically impossible to construct.
The Rubin vase, also known as the Rubin face or the figure-ground vase, is a famous optical illusion in which the image of a vase can also be perceived as two faces in profile looking at each other.
The duck-rabbit illusion is an optical illusion that is an image that can be perceived as either a duck or a rabbit depending on how the viewer looks at it.
The Necker cube is an optical illusion that features a simple wireframe drawing of a cube. The cube appears to switch back and forth between two different orientations.
The My Wife and My Mother-in-Law illusion is an optical illusion with an image of a young woman’s face that can also be perceived as an older woman’s face.
The Schröder Staircase is an optical illusion that features a drawing of a staircase. The staircase appears to be either ascending or descending, depending on how the brain interprets the angles of the lines.
The impossible cube is an optical illusion that depicts a three-dimensional object that is physically impossible to construct.
The impossible trident is a three-pronged impossible shape resembling a trident. It is usually depicted as a three-pronged fork with each prong appearing to be a continuation of the next, creating an impossible shape.
The spinning dancer illusion is a visual illusion that depicts a silhouette of a dancer spinning clockwise or counterclockwise. The direction of the dancer’s spin can appear to change depending on the viewer’s perception
The impossible cylinder is an impossible shape resembling a cylinder similar to the Penrose triangle, impossible cube, and the impossible trident.
The Shepard elephant illusion is an optical illusion that was created by the artist David H. Shepard. The illusion is a black-and-white line drawing of an elephant that appears to be three-dimensional and in motion, despite being a flat, static image.
The illusion is created by using a technique called “anamorphosis,” which involves distorting an image in a specific way so that when it is viewed from a certain angle or perspective, it appears to be in a different form or shape.
Discovery of Multistable Perception
The phenomenon of multistable perception has been observed and studied by many researchers over the years, and it is not typically attributed to a single individual or discovery.
However, one early researcher who is often credited with pioneering the study of multistable perception is the Dutch psychologist Adriaan de Groot. In the 1940s, de Groot conducted a series of experiments on ambiguous figures, including the Necker Cube, and described how these figures could be perceived in multiple, equally valid ways. He also proposed a model for how the brain processes these ambiguous stimuli, which involved competition between different neural representations.
Other researchers who have contributed to the study of multistable perception include the American psychologist Roger Shepard, who introduced the concept of “perceptual switching” in the 1950s, and the British psychologist Colin Blakemore, who studied the neural mechanisms underlying bistable perception in the 1970s.
Overall, multistable perception is a complex and multifaceted phenomenon that has been studied by many researchers across different fields of psychology and neuroscience.
Adriaan de Groot and Multistable Perception
Adriaan de Groot (1914-2006) was a Dutch psychologist who is known for his contributions to the study of cognitive psychology, particularly in the area of human problem-solving and perception.
De Groot received his PhD in psychology from the University of Amsterdam in 1946, and went on to become a professor of psychology at the same university. He conducted influential research on topics such as chess expertise, problem-solving strategies, and perception, and was a pioneer in the use of think-aloud protocols to study cognitive processes.
One of de Groot’s most famous contributions to psychology was his study of chess expertise. In the 1960s, he conducted a series of experiments in which he asked expert and novice chess players to think aloud while they solved chess problems. He found that expert players were able to recognize and remember chess patterns more quickly and accurately than novices, and that their superior performance was due in part to their ability to chunk information into meaningful units.
De Groot also conducted influential research on perception, including his work on ambiguous figures such as the Necker Cube. He proposed a model of perception that involved competition between different neural representations of a stimulus, which could lead to multistable perception and perceptual switching.
Overall, de Groot was a pioneering figure in the field of cognitive psychology, and his work has had a lasting impact on our understanding of human cognition and perception.
The Penroses and Multistable Perception
One of the more famous Multistable Perception illusions, the Penrose stairs, was first created by the British mathematician and physicist Roger Penrose and his father Lionel Penrose, a psychiatrist and mathematician, in the 1950s.
Sir Roger Penrose is a renowned British mathematical physicist and Nobel laureate. He was born in 1931 and is still active today. He is known for his work in the fields of cosmology, general relativity, and quantum mechanics. He was awarded the Nobel Prize in Physics in 2020, jointly with Reinhard Genzel and Andrea Ghez, for his contributions to the understanding of the properties of black holes.
Penrose’s research has focused on the fundamental nature of space and time and the structure of the universe, he proposed new ways of understanding the Big Bang, black holes, and the nature of the universe itself. He has also been interested in the connection between physics and mathematics, particularly in the area of geometry. Penrose has written several books on these topics, which have been widely read and discussed by both scientists and the general public.
Penrose is also known for his work on the concept of “cosmic censorship” which is a theory that states that the singularities that occur in black holes are always hidden from the outside observer. He also developed new mathematical techniques, such as the Penrose diagram, which are used to describe the behavior of black holes and other singularities. Penrose is considered one of the most influential theoretical physicist of the 20th century and his work has had a significant impact on our understanding of the universe.
References and Resources
Check out our complete list of illusions.
Sign Up to Have Your Mind Blown